Nico at the Gatsby Mansion
Nico's restaurant offers an upscale dining experience in a romantic environment. Located inside the famous Gatsby Mansion, guests can enjoy privacy velvet drapes, upholstered wingback chairs and, upon request, a "wine table" nestled next to the wine cellar. Serving lunch and dinner, the menu includes paninis, wraps, pasta, veal, chicken, seafood and steaks. Dishes offered include pan seared salmon, veal marsala, risotto barolo, baked clams and grilled skirt steak. Extensive dessert, wine and martini menus are available. The prices are moderate.
Nico at The Gatsby Mansion
712 Main St.
Islip, NY 11751
(631) 581-1900
nicoatthegatsbymansion.com
Tellers Restaurant
At Tellers Restaurant, diners are treated to 30-foot ceilings and an art deco ambiance. Private rooms are available, as are tables near fireplaces. Menus cover salads, seafood, burgers, pasta, steak and chicken. Entrees include New England style lobster roll, lobster pasta, crispy skin salmon, swordfish, rack of lamb, surf and turf, and steak. Extensive sushi and raw bar dishes are also offered. An in-house wine cellar boasts over 10,000 bottles and 1,000 labels of wine. Prices are moderate to high.
Tellers Restaurant
605 Main St.
Islip, NY 11751
(631) 277-7070
tellerschophouse.com
H2O Restaurant
H2O Seafood Grill and Sushi Bar provides an elegant meal experience in a relaxed atmosphere. Decor is crisp, and the dining areas are split up by French doors. The dinner menu covers appetizers, salads, seafood, steak and sushi. Bamboo-steamed halibut, seafood crepes, pacific rim mussels, grilled porterhouse lamb chops, filet mignon wellington, lobster and various rolls are all offered. For a special occasion, try the Special Wednesday Night Wine dinner menu. Prices vary from reasonable to moderate.
H2O Restaurant
215 W Main St.
Smithtown, NY 11787
(631) 361-6464
h2oseafoodgrill.com
