Proietti's Italian Restaurant
Proietti's Italian Restaurant has been serving authentic Italian cuisine in Webster for parts of four decades. Founded as a pizzeria, the restaurant serves an extensive menu, including classic Italian favorites alongside more modern interpretations. Catering and a party room also are offered.
980 Ridge Road E.
Webster, NY 14580
(585) 872-2330
proiettis.com/welcome.cfm
Castaway's on the Lake
At Castaway's, diners can enjoy unobstructed views of Lake Ontario from the outdoor dining area. Boat docking is available for maritime stopovers. The menu features plenty of seafood, along with steak, chicken and pasta dishes. Catering also is available for groups up to 50.
244 Lake Road
Webster, NY 14580
(585) 323-2943
castawaysonthelake.com
Bill Gray's
With a location in Webster. Bill Gray's is an upstate New York hamburger chain that's a favorite with visitors and locals alike. Webster was home to the original location in 1938. Chicken and seafood compliment the many burger offerings, all in a casual atmosphere. Take-out is available.
941 Hard Road
Webster, NY 14580
(585) 671-0584
billgrays.com
Hedges Nine Mile Point Restaurant
Operating since 1928, Hedges has been run by five generations of the same family. Housed in an historic hotel building, Hedges offers a seafood menu along with classic American dishes and a kids menu. The wine list is extensive and features several regional selections.
1290 Lake Road
Webster, NY 14580-9709
(585) 265-3850
hedgesninemilepoint.com
Maria's Mexican Restaurant
One of Webster's hidden gems, Maria's Mexican Restaurant is a full-service restaurant serving Mexican cuisine and deluxe mixed drinks at the full bar. The lively, family-friendly atmosphere is as big a draw as the food. To complete a meal, many diners opt for a slice of the homemade Kahlua pie.
75 W Main St.
Webster, NY 14580-2903
(585) 872-1237
mariasmexican.com
