Old Mill Inn
The Old Mill Inn offers both indoor and outdoor dining and is located on Mattituck Inlet. The Inn is styled as an old schooner, with water views available from the indoor dining area. The restaurant specializes in fresh local seafood. The Long Island oysters are a special treat. The catch of the day depends on what is local and available. Steaks also are available, and the grilled filet mignon is tender and flavorful.
5775 W. Mill Road
Mattituck, NY 11952
(631) 298-8080
theoldmillinn.net
Touch of Venice
Touch of Venice is located close to the Mattituck Inlet and has both indoor and outdoor dining. The dining room is romantic and elegant, highlighted by a fireplace that is cozy in the winter. The food is rustic Italian, and a specialty is gamberi alla griglia--grilled shrimp in a garlic and lemon sauce over a bed of capellini. A favorite appetizer is the Little Neck clams dusted with sopressata and drizzled with olive oil.
2255 Wickham Ave.
Mattituck, NY 11952
(631) 298-5851
touchofvenice.com
Pine Grove Inn
The Pine Grove Inn located in nearby East Patchogue is a waterfront restaurant that offers indoor and outdoor dining. The restaurant specializes in German cuisine and fresh, local fish and seafood. Its Blue Point oyster appetizer is a standout as is its classic sauerbraten. On Sundays it serves a buffet brunch. On weekends it has live music.
Pine Grove Inn
1 First St.
East Patchogue, NY 11772
(631) 475-9843
pinegroveinn.com
Article Written By Denise Sodaro
Denise Sodaro is a career writer. Her articles have appeared in many magazines and newspapers, including the New York Times and Newsday. Her interests are eclectic; ranging from pet care to medicine and everything in between. Sodaro writes fiction and screenplays, several of which have won awards. She has a Bachelor of Science from Cornell University and a Master of Science from Adelphi University.
