Buona Fortuna Ristorante
Buona Fortuna means "good fortune" and that is exactly what you'll find at this beautiful restaurant. The specialty here is northern Italian food and there are many appetizing dishes on the menu, including a Black Angus Shell Steak and Pollo Florentina (Florentine Chicken). Buona Fortuna has a relaxing atmosphere that is great for anyone that has been on their feet, hiking the parks around Monticello.
Buona Fortuna Ristorante
46 Forestburgh Road
Monticello, NY
(845) 796-4110
buonafortunany.com
The Old Homestead Restaurant
Just like almost everything else in New England, The Old Homestead Restaurant has a long history and is overflowing with hospitality. Unlike most other restaurants, however, The Old Homestead Restaurant doesn't actually have a written menu. Instead, the staff explains the specials and recites the menu from memory. This helps create a relationship between the restaurant staff and clientele. The Homestead Restaurant has a superb ribeye steak, but it is well known for its famous homemade desserts, like the delicious banana cream pie. Once you're done with the slopes at Holiday Mountain Ski Area, make sure you come in for a warm and hearty meal at The Old Homestead Restaurant
The Old Homestead Restaurant
452 Bridgeville Road
Monticello, NY
(845) 794-8973
theoldhomesteadny.com
The Wet Noodle
The Wet Noodle might not look like anything at all from the outside and if you're just driving by, you'd probably miss it. Sure, it is a small restaurant, but it serves some of the best pizza in Monticello. When you come into The Wet Noodle, make sure that you ask for the Buffalo Chicken Specialty Pizza. Or, you might try another specialty, like the Chicken Cheddar Bacon Pie. Nothing will relax you more after a long day canoeing at one of the lakes near Monticello like a warm pizza pie.
The Wet Noodle
42 Kitz Road
Monticello, NY
(845) 794-4800
the-wet-noodle.com
