Shimano Vs. Campagnolo

Shimano Vs. Campagnolo
pignons de dérailleur de vélo image by Cyril PAPOT from Fotolia.com

What To Look For

Campagnolo and Shimano offer high-end road groups. In 2010, Campagnolo introduced Super Record 11 and Shimano revealed Dura-Ace Di2. By Campagnolo moving into 11 cogs on a wheel and Shimano using electricity and motors to shift, these companies have each taken on separate paths of technological advancement. Selection of high-end components depends on riding preferences, weight and cost. Di2 is the most expensive at more than $4,800 compared with Super Record 11 at just more than $3,000. Super Record 11 is lighter, but Di2 eliminates cables and the need to trim.

Common Pitfalls

Shimano and Campagnolo have brake levers that also function as shifters. The shifters are the most complicated component on road bicycles and are made up of many small parts. Campagnolo offers these small parts for sale and have designed the shifters to be serviced. Shimanos shifters cannot be serviced. Campagnolo is not as widely available as Shimano and its lower-end groups like Chorus and Athena cost more than their Shimano counterparts.

Where To Buy

High-end groups such as Super Record 11 and Di2 perform their best when installed by trained technicians. Find a bicycle shop that sells and repairs high-end race bikes and talk about what's right for your budget, riding style and bike. Buying parts from Internet retailers may be less expensive, but a shop familiar with the groups will get the right components and install them correctly. A bike shop may also offer a package deal for future adjustment or service.

Cost

Outfitting your bike with Campagnolo Super Record 11 can cost more than $3,000 depending on the installation cost and component selection. Shimano's Dura-Ace Di2 could set you back more than $4,800 depending upon installation costs and component selection. Dura-Ace also has a traditional cable system available for around $2,600. Dura-Ace groups come with a three-year factory warranty in case of malfunctions. Campagnolo provides warranties for a period of three or four years.

Comparison Shopping

SRAM also designs and manufactures high-end road bike component groups. Some professional racers prefer the performance of SRAM Red over Dura-Ace and Super Record. Red is also very close in weight and costs significantly less than Dura-Ace and Super Record 11 groups, giving it a strong advantage in the marketplace.

Insider Tips

Chances are you'll be spending hours sitting in the cockpit of your bike. It's important to choose a system that matches your riding style. Take the time to try out the different systems and get a feel for how each system engages the gear change at the cassette. Consider how it feels to shift while resting on the hoods or in the drop position. The feel of the system is an important consideration especially when selecting a system for a racing bicycle.

Article Written By Tim McGivern

An outdoor enthusiast, Timothy McGivern has been writing about his adventures since 2005. He founded "The Sustainable Cyclist" in 2008 and maintains a personal blog covering rock climbing experiences throughout the United States. He is a bicycle mechanic, licensed engineer and holds a Bachelor of Science in civil engineering from Union College.

Write for Trails.com
  • Editor's Pick

    Backcountry Camping Tips

    Backcountry Camping Tips

    You've already tried car and RV camping. You've camped at commercial campsites that had a convenient restroom and water supply. Now, you want to explore the road less traveled. Backcountry camping, also known as primitive camping, is a wonderful way to explore the remote...

    More Backcountry Camping...
  • Popular Article

    Beach Camping Near Pismo Beach, California

    Beach Camping Near Pismo Beach, California

    Pismo State Beach, California, has many attractions and activities including camping, swimming, hiking and wildlife viewing. Birdwatching is one of the primary activities in the area. The park also has the largest over-wintering colony of monarch butterflies in the natio...

    More Beach Camping...
  • Featured Video

    Common Sense Hiking Tips

    Common Sense Hiking Tips

    The first and most fundamental thing is never hike alone. There are too many situations, especially as an unexperienced hiker, where you may find yourself without anyone to help you. So the buddy system works and applies very much in hiking.

    More Camping Basics...

Outdoor Gear & Equipment

ALL NEW Trails Gear Store powered by:

Trail Finder

US Map

Search by Keyword