A Comparison of Yakima and Thule

A Comparison of Yakima and Thule

What To Look For

When it comes to a roof rack for your skis, bike, kayak and other outdoor gear, savvy folks know that the go-to brands are Yakima and Thule. To an extent, many of the accessories can be used interchangeably between the two systems. Yakima's main load bars are round, while Thule's are square. Thule seems to be favored by kayakers, who feel that the load stackers from Thule are better. For ski racks, the Thule Flattop includes locking hardware, while with Yakima, it needs to be bought separately. Both Thule and Yakima make ski carriers, bike carriers and kayak carriers that fit existing factory mounts.

Common Pitfalls

Weight is a key component of a system's compatibility with your car. For lighter-weight items like skis, you can often pass on getting bars and use Thule or Yakima universal mounts to attach the mount to your factory crossbars. For heavier loads, like multiple kayaks or using cargo boxes, having the Thule or Yakima crossbars attached to the car is best, as it provides more stability for the heavier loads.

Some cars will work better with certain racks than others. Your local dealer can help with deciding on the proper system for your vehicle. When buying a rack, decide what the maximum amount of gear you are going to carry will be, so that you only buy once. Buying a four-ski carrier when you will need room to carry a snowboard and four pairs of skis won't work.

Where To Buy

REI is one of the largest dealers in the world of both Yakima and Thule products. Rack Attack (see resources) is another good source of both brands, and their stores usually have mounting techs who can mount the rack for you.

Cost

Ski, bike and kayak carriers from Thule and Yakima are priced between $120 and $200 (2010 prices). Most of these can mount to an existing factory system. If you need to get a base bar system to mount the carriers on, the bars and mounts will cost between $250 and $400 (2010 prices). Cargo boxes are priced between $500 and $700. Locks for the bars and carriers are $20 per lock.

Resources

Article Written By Candace Horgan

Candace Horgan has worked as a freelance journalist for more than 12 years. Her work has appeared in various print and online publications, including the "Denver Post" and "Mix." Horgan holds a Bachelor of Arts in English and history.

Write for Trails.com
  • Editor's Pick

    Backcountry Camping Tips

    Backcountry Camping Tips

    You've already tried car and RV camping. You've camped at commercial campsites that had a convenient restroom and water supply. Now, you want to explore the road less traveled. Backcountry camping, also known as primitive camping, is a wonderful way to explore the remote...

    More Backcountry Camping...
  • Popular Article

    Beach Camping Near Pismo Beach, California

    Beach Camping Near Pismo Beach, California

    Pismo State Beach, California, has many attractions and activities including camping, swimming, hiking and wildlife viewing. Birdwatching is one of the primary activities in the area. The park also has the largest over-wintering colony of monarch butterflies in the natio...

    More Beach Camping...
  • Featured Video

    Common Sense Hiking Tips

    Common Sense Hiking Tips

    The first and most fundamental thing is never hike alone. There are too many situations, especially as an unexperienced hiker, where you may find yourself without anyone to help you. So the buddy system works and applies very much in hiking.

    More Camping Basics...

Outdoor Gear & Equipment

ALL NEW Trails Gear Store powered by:

Trail Finder

US Map

Search by Keyword